Australia’s most famous musicians, writers and artists are united in their criticism of the ongoing AI harvest of their work. Big tech is using their work and offering them nothing in return.
The Australian Performing Right Association (APRA) has launched a new campaign called “Not theirs to take” with a range of supporters including the Australian Society of Authors, The Guardian, Copyright Australia and ARIA. The campaign encourages people to sign a petition, encourages people to write to their local member and respond to a poll about the relationship Australian creators should have to the content they create.
This launch is in the wake of comments from former Australian Competition and Consumer Commission boss, Rod Sims, that the current proposals the Albanese government is considering could make Australia a copyright “tax haven” for mega artificial intelligence companies.
Sims is one of the authors of the News Media Bargaining Code (NMBC), an Australian innovation that ensured big tech companies such as Meta and Alphabet (the parent companies of Facebook and Google) would pay Australia media for using their content.
In the same way that Australia has regulated cigarette packaging, the NMBC demonstrates it is possible for the federal government to stand up on behalf of its citizens against seemingly unconquerable foreign companies, just as Australia did when it regulated cigarette packaging.
Sims was in part responding to news from the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence, which quoted Anthropic as saying, “We understand there is consideration of some sort of conditional approval, which is close to a form of statutory authorisation with conditions attached”. What worries arts advocates, and those keen for Australia to maintain local culture and fair return on writing, painting, film and more, is that changing the laws to ease their use of copyrighted work will not only harm artists but also set a dangerous precedent.
It’s not just Australian artists who find a copyright carve-out unconscionable. This week, the head of the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry, which represents the recording industry around the world, asked why Australia would trade exemptions to copyright law for the promise that big tech would build data centres in Australia.
Get our newsletter
Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.
Australia has a long history of allowing multinationals to take advantage of our resources while giving little in exchange, including our gas, minerals, water and arable farmland. By this logic, poorly regulated data centres taking advantage of Australian electricity and cultural content are just the next form of extractive industry.
Just as Australia took a leading role on the NMBC, standing up to multinationals and in turn supporting our local media, so Australia could lead the world in ensuring that Australian creators are properly remunerated for their work.
In the past, Australia has lost out by slavishly following the United States. Ironically, 20 years ago, Australia made copyright law stricter at the behest of US companies, some of the same forces that now want Australia to loosen copyright law. One of the negotiation points in Australia’s so-called Free Trade Agreement with the United States, which meant lengthening the copyright term from 50 years after the death of the creator to 70 years. This was all to match the American term, which had been extended at the behest of Disney.
This extension means that creative works are kept out of the public domain for longer – often in the vaults of large companies that are doing little with them – instead of being available for anyone to enjoy, and perhaps use to create new works. The works of JRR Tolkein and Agatha Christie, among many others, would have entered the public domain in Australia if it had not been for the US-driven copyright extension. And now instead of advocating for a more liberal copyright regime for everyone, the AI companies are trying to negotiate special copyright exemptions for themselves.
The new campaign, “Not theirs to take”, is a good start. It is a way for creators to communicate to their elected representatives that this issue matters to them and to remind politicians of the central role of culture in Australian life.
But the campaign alone will not be enough. Action on AI in Australia will require foresight and fortitude from the Albanese government to emulate historical successes such as the NMBC and unbranded cigarette packaging and avoid mistakes of the past such as giving away the country’s gas for free.