Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

FACTCHECK

Factcheck: No, private schools are not bastions of diversity

In an op-ed published in the Sydney Morning Herald, chair of Independent Schools NSW Margery Evans argues that Jane Caro’s Rich Kid Poor Kid Vantage Point essay generalises and misinterprets the state of Australian education. But in doing so, Evans does exactly what she accuses Caro of, misleading the reader about the actual state of private school education.

By Skye Predavec

Tue 19 May 2026 01.00 AEST

Society & InequalityEducation
Misleading
Factcheck: No, private schools are not bastions of diversity

Photo: AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts

Republish this article

This article is licensed under Creative Commons — Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0).

Republishing guidelines

  • You must credit the author(s) and The Point.
  • You must link back to the original article.
  • You may not edit or modify the article content.
  • Images may be subject to separate copyright and are not included in this licence.

In “Private schools aren’t full of rich kids – here’s the evidence”, an op-ed published in the Sydney Morning Herald, chair of Independent Schools NSW Margery Evans (who represents non-Catholic-Church-run private schools) argues that Jane Caro’s Rich Kid Poor Kid Vantage Point essay generalises and misinterprets the state of Australian education.

But in doing so, Evans does exactly what she accuses Caro of, misleading the reader about the actual state of private school education.

This is most clear with the throughline of the piece, the idea that independent schools have taken on a surge of low-income, multicultural students in Western Sydney, not just “rich kids” like they used to.

“Your typical Independent school is now more likely to be a low-fee, culturally diverse school in western Sydney educating children with diverse learning needs from lower-than-average-income families.”

Let’s break that down.

Is Western Sydney full of independent schools?

The key to Evans’ claim is “more likely”. It’s probably true that a student in Western Sydney is more likely to go to an independent school than they used to be, just like any other student – independent schools have grown significantly over the past few decades.

But Evans’ implication is clearly wider than that – that the average independent school student is no longer a wealthy, white Anglo-Saxon Protestant from Sydney’s North, or East.

On that, this supposed glut of students coming to Western Sydney’s independent schools has barely shifted the needle.

In fact, Fairfield in Western Sydney has the lowest share of students attending independent schools in the entire city, just 7%. The most? Woollahra, in the Eastern Suburbs, with almost 60% of students.

Fairfield is one of the poorest places in NSW, while Woollahra is the most affluent local council in Australia. That’s hardly surprising with private school fees reaching double digits, growing faster than inflation.

What about income?

It’s true that Australia’s independent schools have taken in more low-income families over the past three decades. But, they’ve also taken in far more high- and middle-income families over the same time period. From 1996 to 2021, independent schools went from educating 6% of students from low-income households to 10%. But over the same period, they jumped ten points to educate one in four high-income students.

That’s from Independent Schools Australia’s own data about the demographics of their students, which also shows that they disproportionately educate those from the richest families. Two in five independent school students come from high income households; more than double the high-income share in public schools.

So, is Evans lying?

No, but her argument is clearly misleading. It is probably technically true that independent schools in Western Sydney have grown by a greater rate than those elsewhere, just not a greater number. Same with low-income students. That’s easy when independent schools have historically been elitist institutions, educating small numbers of lower income students.

If a school educated 100 students, for example, adding one more would mean it grew by 1%. But if it only educated a single student, taking in a second one would mean the number of students doubled.

It’s technically true that the one-student school had stronger enrolment growth, even though it took the exact same number of new students as the 100-student school. While it isn’t lying, Evans is using this rhetorical trick to make the reader think that independent schools are far more diverse than they actually are.

It’s a trick used throughout the article.

Another, similar claim is that “The strongest enrolment growth has been in independent schools charging less than $5000 per year.”

Is that true?

According to Independent Schools Australia, independent schools charging less than $5000 per year grew by 31.8% from 2019 to 2024, while the more expensive independent schools grew by 14%. Technically, Evans is being accurate here.

But digging into the numbers tells a different story. Almost 60% of the growth went to schools charging over $5000 per year, which make up three quarters of all independent schools.

In fact, independent schools charging no fees grew by 160%, more than doubling from 2019 to 2024 – because they educate less than 10,000 students nationwide.

It’s the same trick as before. Because there are so few cheap independent schools compared to expensive ones, it’s easy for them to have a higher growth rate. But it’s misleading to pretend that growth rate is the entire story.

Evans jokes that Caro must have “not seen an Independent school since the introduction of colour television.” Even if she hadn’t, Sydneysiders like Caro can’t help but see boys in boaters in North Sydney or the handsome sandstone of Sydney Grammar and Saint Catherine’s.

But with an op-ed full of misleading and misdirecting claims, Evans is the one trying to make the Sydney Morning Herald’s readers see in black and white.

Verdict: Misleading.

Advertisement

Related Articles

OPINION

Adding life to our years, not years to our lives

By Luke Slawomirski

How long we live is only part of the story. What matters just as much is how long we remain healthy. And on that measure, we have a problem.

Society & InequalityHealth
Adding life to our years, not years to our lives

OPINION

All discrimination is wrong, unless you are a kid from a poor family

By Jane Caro AM

Discrimination is literally what private, fee-charging schools are about. They are transactional, designed to provide a private and positional good for the families who can pay their fees. Only public schools have any obligation to the public good – aka educating every child. The clue is in the name.

Society & Inequality
All discrimination is wrong, unless you are a kid from a poor family

OPINION

Victorian children who commit minor and low-level crimes don’t need ‘tough love’. They need connection and prevention

By David Jeffery

The Victorian Premier’s announcement of mandatory court-ordered rehabilitation for young people found guilty of low-level offences such as theft, vandalism, property damage and minor assaults isn’t entirely without merit. But the money could be better spent than on youth prison. Those of us working in youth and community services know that lasting reductions in crime come from prevention.

Society & Inequality
Victorian children who commit minor and low-level crimes don’t need ‘tough love’. They need connection and prevention

OPINION

What is the Sustainable Bond Market and what’s happening in Australia?

By Brad Hiller & Rod Campbell

Australia is facing a defining question: how to finance the trillions required for a sustainable, inclusive and resilient future without overwhelming public budgets. As climate, housing, and environmental pressures intensify, one option that is gaining traction is green, social and sustainability (GSS) bonds.

ClimateEducation
What is the Sustainable Bond Market and what’s happening in Australia?