Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

Parliamentary process and open government might be more fruitful ground for Liberals than “Melongate” has been

The Liberal–National Opposition is in a difficult parliamentary position. Still smarting from the worst result in Liberal Party history, they are not a live threat as an alternative government to a Labor Party that holds almost two in every three seats. Nor has the party distinguished itself on policy. 

Bill Browne

Bill Browne

Fri 21 Aug 2026 01.00 AEST

Democracy & Accountability
Parliamentary process and open government might be more fruitful ground for Liberals than “Melongate” has been

Photo: AAP Image/Mick Tsikas

The Liberal–National Opposition is in a difficult parliamentary position. Still smarting from the worst result in Liberal Party history, they are not a live threat as an alternative government to a Labor Party that holds almost two in every three seats.

Nor has the party distinguished itself on policy. As Amy Remeikis points out, the Coalition spent this sitting fortnight attacking the Prime Minister’s comments about women because little distinguishes Liberal and Labor on NDIS cuts, fossil fuels, gambling and defence. There’s no hay to be made from furious agreement.

But there is hope for the Opposition. A party does not have to be the alternative government to shape the political agenda. This year, independent David Pocock has elevated a gas export tax to a national debate. During the Coalition years, the Greens and independents pursued an anti-corruption commission through the Senate even though it had no hope of passing the House of Representatives. That laid the groundwork for Labor’s National Anti-Corruption Commission.

State crossbenchers and oppositions forced the disclosure of Cabinet decisions in Tasmania and timely disclosure of government reports in Victoria. The Coalition and Greens could do the same in the federal Senate.

And while integrity has not been the Coalition’s strong point, the Labor Government has disappointed in that department too – with an anti-corruption commission that has never held a public hearing and a Freedom of Information system that costs more than ever to give the public as little information as possible.

The Coalition has already created trouble for the Labor Government on transparency issues. Last year Attorney-General Michelle Rowland introduced harsh restrictions on Australians’ right to information. With the Greens and independents, the Coalition voted down these changes.

This was something of a surprise. Often, oppositions will wave through changes that increase the power and autonomy of the government, because the opposition expects soon to become the government. The Coalition’s rejection of government secrecy suggests that they see themselves as so far from government that they have more to gain than lose from transparency.

Another hint of the compact between major parties falling apart came last year when Coalition, Greens and independent senators voted to lengthen Question Time.

Labor threatened in turn to cut pay for Liberal–National MPs in the House of Representatives by taking away their deputy chair positions.

What do deputy chairs in the lower house have to do with a motion in the upper house?

Only that Labor controls the lower house, so that’s where it can make the Opposition feel pain. Just as oppositions often vote with government, governments often give oppositions special privileges (and therefore higher pay) because one day the boot will be on the other foot.

Each major party shares with the other – until one party breaks the arrangement.

The Coalition backed down and Senate Question Time was shortened again – but the seed was planted.

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

If the Coalition were not afraid of the “We’ll do the same to you in government” threat, what could they do today to both improve government accountability and make trouble for Labor?

In the Senate, the Coalition, Greens and independents have the numbers to:

  • Choose the President of the Senate from an independent or minor party, instead of from the governing party (Labor in this case). 
  • Choose chairs of the eight committees that scrutinise legislation from the Opposition or the crossbench, instead of from government senators. Reports might be more collaborative and probing with a chair from another party.
  • Call ministers from the House of Representatives to give evidence at Senate Estimates, instead of letting them send a senator as delegate.
  • Refuse to vote on government legislation until the government has produced all the information the Senate has ordered. 
  • Sanction government ministers who ignore the Senate’s orders, as Labor has tried before.

These reforms could improve process in the Parliament and hold the Labor Government to account.

Integrity and good process should be red meat for conservative MPs and voters.

The Fraser Coalition Government enacted the first Freedom of Information laws and created the Commonwealth Ombudsman and the Human Rights Commission. In this parliament, Liberal Senator Paul Scarr has distinguished himself in his support of whistleblowers. His colleague, Senator Richard Colbeck, proposed laws – which the Australia Institute supported – that would have put parliamentary checks and balances on government use of management consultants.

Integrity and open government could prove safer ground for the Opposition than economic, social and cultural debates where the party either cannot find internal agreement or what they can agree on has proven unpopular with Australian voters.

A muscular and independent Senate would be a constructive way of making trouble for the Coalition’s Labor rivals, and improve Australian government to boot.

Related Articles

OPINION

Is Victoria about to abandon the values that set it apart?

By Daniel James

At stake in this election is something even more fundamental than transitioning from one centrist party to another in the offing. For this isn’t a case of a defeated John Brumby handing over the keys to Spring Street to Ted Baillieu, a Labor economic conservative, to a moderate liberal conservative. This shift, if it happens, will be something completely different.

Democracy & Accountability
Is Victoria about to abandon the values that set it apart?

OPINION

Draconian laws and dereliction of duty – and it all took less than an hour

By Amy Remeikis

Depending on what time you read this, Labor and the Coalition will have passed one of the most consequential and autocratic changes to Australia’s defence powers in half a century. And they will have done it with the barest debate possible.

Democracy & Accountability
Draconian laws and dereliction of duty – and it all took less than an hour

OFF THE CHARTS

Victoria’s major parties are sinking to record lows

By Skye Predavec

One Nation’s rise is only half the picture. Hanson’s party, The Greens, minor parties and independents could collectively receive a majority of the vote.

Democracy & Accountability
Victoria’s major parties are sinking to record lows

OPINION

Heavy-handed response to protesters a reminder all is not well in Australia

By Bill Browne

On the weekend, hundreds of Australians took to Newcastle Harbour to protest Australia’s climate hypocrisy: ramping up gas and coal exports even as it claims to be a “climate leader”. But the peaceful protest, which was pulled off without incident or even any arrests, happened against the best efforts of NSW Police.

Democracy & Accountability
Heavy-handed response to protesters a reminder all is not well in Australia