Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

Australia cannot lead abroad and expand coal at home

There’s tension in the air at this pre-COP. Tension between Pacific Island states and Australia. Tension over the world leaders who have not turned up. Tension over Australia’s continued expansion of coal and gas, even as it asks to be applauded for its climate leadership. And tension over how to call out a powerful partner whose aid and cooperation you still need.

Noah Schultz-Byard

Noah Schultz-Byard

Wed 7 Oct 2026 10.17 AEDT

ClimateInternational Affairs
Australia cannot lead abroad and expand coal at home

Photo: Supplied

Republish this article

This article is licensed under Creative Commons — Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0).

Republishing guidelines

  • You must credit the author(s) and The Point.
  • You must link back to the original article.
  • You may not edit or modify the article content.
  • Images may be subject to separate copyright and are not included in this licence.

As planes descend into Fiji this week, passengers are being welcomed with a message that captures both the hope and the pressure surrounding the Pacific’s pre-COP climate summit.

“As the national airline of a small island developing state on the frontlines of climate change, we are proud to fly you here to experience our Pacific realities firsthand. We thank you for your commitment to holding the line on science and keeping the 1.5°C target within reach.”

It is a generous welcome. But it is also a challenge.

Delegates are being asked to confront what their decisions mean for the people hosting them. 

Tension in the Pacific

There’s tension in the air at this pre-COP.

Tension between Pacific Island states and Australia. Tension over the world leaders who have not turned up. Tension over Australia’s continued expansion of coal and gas, even as it asks to be applauded for its climate leadership.

And tension over how to call out a powerful partner whose aid and cooperation you still need.

That is a difficult dance for Pacific governments. But at a pre-COP stakeholder event on Tuesday, community advocates were not dodging the issue. “Climate colonisation” was among the descriptions discussed by Vishal Prasad, director of Pacific Islands Students Fighting Climate Change, and other panellists.

“From a legal standpoint (fossil fuel expansion) is completely unacceptable under the law and not tenable with what the International Court of Justice has said,” Prasad said.

“The ICJ talked about the licensing, exploration, and subsidies of fossil fuels as potentially being an illegal act under international law, and that does not seem to be factored in by the Australian Government.”

His verdict on Australia’s leadership at this COP was equally sharp.

“Australia is taking the complete opposite track in addressing climate change, meeting its legal obligations and being the Presidency of COP that we are hoping it should be.”

Contradictions at home

Australia should be listening to the impassioned voices of young leaders like Prasad. Instead, it keeps giving its critics fresh material.

Last week, the NSW Independent Planning Commission approved the extension of Hunter Valley Operations (HVO) coal mine, allowing it to produce coal to 2045 and emit over 800 million tonnes of climate pollution while doing so.

That’s decades more coal, locked in on the eve of a Pacific climate summit.

It is hard to imagine a clearer illustration of the gap between the climate leadership Australia claims and the fossil fuel future it continues to enable.

What makes it all the more baffling is the fact that this conference really matters to Australia. Canberra wants strong Pacific partnerships, not least because it wants to counter China’s growing influence in the region. But our Pacific neighbours’ demand for a genuine transition away from fossil fuels is a test of whether those relationships mean what Australia says they do.

We want our Pacific family’s trust. We want their partnership. We want credit for standing beside them.

We just keep making decisions that directly undermine their future.

Australia has spent years trying to repair its standing in the Pacific. Our record gives us plenty to repair. Who can forget Peter Dutton’s remark about time meaning nothing when water is lapping at your door?

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

But time means everything to the Pacific.

Time is measured in rising seas, salinated water supplies, threatened homelands and displaced communities. It is measured in how much can still be protected, and how much will be lost while governments find another excuse to delay.

What this region does not have time for is more obfuscation dressed up as climate diplomacy.

That is why the thin turnout of world leaders at this event has been so disappointing.

“We were hoping for more,” Vanuatu’s climate minister, Ralph Regenvanu, told Reuters ahead of the summit. “It just reflects the lack of attention and priority given to what Pacific nations consider the greatest threat to their future.”

Where to, for COP, from here? 

Last month, the UN Environment Programme warned that global warming is set to cross 1.5°C, likely within the next few years, and called for immediate, sustained emissions cuts.

That report highlights the ultimate tension on the ground here: maintaining hope in the face of worsening climate damage and the deliberate extension of the fossil-fuel economy by supposed allies like Australia.

The generosity of the welcome Australia has received in Fiji should not be confused with acceptance. Nor should diplomatic restraint be mistaken for an endless supply of patience.

For Australia’s Climate Minister, Chris Bowen, this conference and COP31 in Antalya are a crucial test.

As President of Negotiations, Bowen has “exclusive authority in relation to the negotiations”.

He cannot force every country to agree to his personally preferred outcome. But Australia has sought and accepted a position from which it can shape the result.

If we cannot demonstrate climate leadership now, while leading the negotiations and partnering with the Pacific, then when will we?

And what does climate leadership mean if not bringing an end to new coal and gas projects at home?

None of this is easy 

Bowen has a bumpy road ahead.

On one side, he faces pressure from his own cabinet colleagues and fossil-fuel companies. On the other are the needs of communities across the Pacific and in Australia fighting to protect their homes and livelihoods.

The difficulty of his task is real. So are the consequences of failure. They are not remotely equivalent.

The Hunter Valley Operations coal mine extension still needs federal environmental approval, which gives the Australian Government a concrete decision to make.

Australia can keep calling itself a climate leader. But if it backs decades more coal while asking Pacific countries to wait their turn, it should not be surprised when they call it something other than leadership.

Hypocrisy is an option that comes quickly to mind.

Noah Schultz-Byard is the Director of Strategic Partnerships at the Australia Institute.

Related Articles

WHAT'S NEW

Shorter America This Week: Men are so embarrassing; It's on; Men are so embarrassing, cont.

By Emma Shortis

In “Shorter America”, Dr Emma Shortis keeps you up-to-date on the United States with news and analysis that you can trust. 

International Affairs
Shorter America This Week: Men are so embarrassing; It's on; Men are so embarrassing, cont.

OPINION

Little Marco Rubio — on Living and Dying by the Sword.

By Allan Behm

What shallow draught had Marco Rubio consumed before he addressed the Federalist Society National Lawyers Convention last week?

International Affairs
Little Marco Rubio — on Living and Dying by the Sword.

WHAT'S NEW

‘The map as we have known it is done’: Democrats break through Republican strongholds

By Tegan George

The political landscape of the United States has been fundamentally redrawn, with Democrats breaking through long-held Republican strongholds after campaigning on cost-of-living pressures and corruption rather than culture wars.

International Affairs
‘The map as we have known it is done’: Democrats break through Republican strongholds

WHAT'S NEW

Over 100 community events bring COP31 conversations home

By Tegan George

More than 100 community events have been held across Australia over the past month, bringing global climate and biodiversity negotiations home as the COP31 climate summit draws to a close.

Climate
Over 100 community events bring COP31 conversations home