Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

Is our constitutional system democratic?

An extract from The People's Guide to the Australian Constitution by Rosalind Dixon and William Partlett, published by UNSW Books

Rosalind Dixon & William Partlett

Rosalind DixonWilliam Partlett

Thu 2 Apr 2026 16.36 AEDT

Democracy & Accountability
Is our constitutional system democratic?

In 1891, the push to adopt an Australian constitution seemed unlikely to succeed. The first attempt produced an unremarkable, lawyerly document, which established an appointed upper house and a system that did not require government ministers to be accountable to popular representatives for their actions and decisions. This draft failed to generate much enthusiasm and was not taken forward. It appeared that the attempt to federate Australia had failed.

A few years later, however, in a remarkable series of events for a British colony thousands of kilometres from Europe, a series of peoples’ gatherings restarted the process. These gatherings devised a new process: the parliaments of each of the colonies would write legislation allowing their people to directly elect representatives to a new constitution-making convention. This new group of elected representatives came together with the explicit purpose of enlarging the Australian people’s powers of self-government. They produced a highly original text that featured an elected upper house and a referendum process for amendment. Although imperfect – notably, it excluded both women and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples – it was, for its time, a radically democratic document.

This text – our Constitution today – combines different forms of democracy. In fact, democracy can mean different things: direct democracy, where everyone has a direct say in making the rules and running the government, or representative democracy, where we elect people to do these tasks on our behalf. Representative democracy has been a foundational value in the Australian Constitution since 1901. The Constitution established a representative institution called parliament – the branch of government that makes laws, debates public policy and holds the executive accountable – as the central institution in our democracy. Moreover, it required that the members of both houses of parliament be elected by the people. This was highly innovative: Australia was the first parliamentary system to have a directly elected upper house. Direct democracy also played a role, as the framers broke with British representative tradition and gave the people the decisive power to amend the Constitution through a referendum.

Democracy can also be understood in narrow and broad senses. The narrow sense involves norms and institutions focused on electoral accountability, or the accountability of elected representatives to the people. This ‘democratic minimum core’ includes the idea of regular, multi-party, free and fair elections, but also political rights and freedoms that give citizens the right to vote, to hold governments to account through protest, to have a free press and to enjoy free speech. And it requires institutions – such as courts – to uphold these commitments. But it is still relatively narrow. Other definitions of democracy are broader, and include things like active public debate among citizens (for example, through citizen assemblies) and the protection of civil rights, such as the right to privacy, freedom of association or belief and political participation, and even socioeconomic rights such as the right of access to food, housing, healthcare and social security.

Australia combines elements of both narrow and broad understandings of democracy. The Constitution provides strong legal protections for the minimum core of democracy, including the textual guarantee that both the upper and lower houses of parliament are ‘directly chosen by the people’. The strength of Australia’s electoral democracy is reinforced by longstanding legislative provisions, including for a system of compulsory voting.

The broader notions of democratic inclusion, trust and participation are in the written Constitution as well, such as a provision empowering the parliament to intervene in private industrial relations between employees and employers. Other mechanisms ensuring these purposes have been left to ordinary legislation, including the creation of powerful guardian institutions such as the Australian Electoral Commission and the National Anti-Corruption Commission, which oversee trust in the voting process and in public administration, respectively. This unique combination of democratic elements was described by James Bryce in 1901 as ‘the high-water mark of popular government’ and ‘penetrated by the spirit of democracy’. US President Teddy Roosevelt declared Australia to be a ‘splendid object lesson’ in representative democracy. Since then, Australian democracy has also developed a number of innovative mechanisms, from compulsory voting to the set of highly respected electoral institutions we note above.

This is an edited extract of The People’s Guide to the Australian Constitution by Rosalind Dixon and William Partlett, published by UNSW Press ($19.99) and available now.

Rosalind Dixon is a Professor of Law at UNSW Sydney, and former assistant professor at the University of Chicago, and visiting professor at Harvard Law, Columbia Law, and Chicago Law Schools.

William Partlett is Associate Professor at the University of Melbourne Law School and Co-Director of its Centre for Comparative Constitutional Studies.

Advertisement

Related Articles

OPINION

Greens and One Nation break into Victorian leaders’ debate thanks to Sky News

By Bill Browne

So, it is thanks to major party self-interest that the two minor parties were invited, and ironic that it will be on Sky News – no friend of the Greens – that the left-wing party makes its debate debut. But what the debate gains in depth, it loses in breadth. Just one debate has been scheduled, and only on subscription-based services.

Democracy & Accountability
Greens and One Nation break into Victorian leaders’ debate thanks to Sky News

OPINION

‘Trust us’ isn’t nearly enough for this overreach – but it will likely work anyway

By Amy Remeikis

The overreach in the defence capability act changes is explained away with “trust us”. Trust us to consult (even though nothing happens if we don’t, and it doesn’t matter if you don’t want what we have decided – you have no rights of appeal).

Democracy & Accountability
‘Trust us’ isn’t nearly enough for this overreach – but it will likely work anyway

OPINION

Where did Labor’s ideas go?

By James Watson

One of the right's cliched critiques is that left governments privilege “ideology” above “reality”. It’s a critique that is both typically meaningless and a way for the right to imply that their own policy ideas are “rational” and “objective”. But in order to make this clichéd critique, you have to first assume that the left government you’re talking about at the very least has some distinct ideas.

Democracy & Accountability
Where did Labor’s ideas go?

OPINION

As nation loses its way on AI-generated deepfakes, NSW debates a better way forward

By Bill Browne

Today, the NSW Parliament will debate the case for truth in political advertising laws. It’s the culmination of a months-long petition in which over 31,000 NSW residents lent their names to the call for a ban on misleading ads.

Democracy & Accountability
As nation loses its way on AI-generated deepfakes, NSW debates a better way forward