Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

Greens and One Nation break into Victorian leaders’ debate thanks to Sky News

So, it is thanks to major party self-interest that the two minor parties were invited, and ironic that it will be on Sky News – no friend of the Greens – that the left-wing party makes its debate debut. But what the debate gains in depth, it loses in breadth. Just one debate has been scheduled, and only on subscription-based services.

Bill Browne

Bill Browne

Tue 17 Nov 2026 11.51 AEDT

Democracy & Accountability
Greens and One Nation break into Victorian leaders’ debate thanks to Sky News

Photo: AAP Image/Con Chronis

Republish this article

This article is licensed under Creative Commons — Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0).

Republishing guidelines

  • You must credit the author(s) and The Point.
  • You must link back to the original article.
  • You may not edit or modify the article content.
  • Images may be subject to separate copyright and are not included in this licence.

Tonight, Ellen Sandell, leader of the Victorian Greens, will have Sky News to thank as she joins Labor Premier Ben Carroll, Liberal Opposition Leader Jess Wilson and One Nation leader Warren Pickering in the leaders’ debate.

The Greens have long argued that, as Australia’s largest minor party, they should be invited to leaders’ debates. The Greens have also called for an independent debates commission that would decide questions like venue, format and invitees, instead of these being decided by ad hoc negotiations.

Commentators on Sky News, now called News24, have pumped One Nation’s tyres for months. Carroll demanded Pickering be included in the Sky News/Herald Sun hosted debate, presumably because Labor wants voters to be reminded that a Liberal–National government may need One Nation support. The Liberals responded by saying the Greens should be invited if One Nation is.

So, it is thanks to major party self-interest that the two minor parties were invited, and ironic that it will be on Sky News – no friend of the Greens – that the left-wing party makes its debate debut.

But what the debate gains in depth, it loses in breadth. Just one debate has been scheduled, rather than three or four, and only on subscription-based services. Neither national broadcaster the ABC nor free-to-air Nine could get the parties to agree on debate rules.

The usual argument for excluding minor parties is that they have no hope of forming government. One Nation’s meteoric rise in the polls has challenged that logic. The far-right minor party came close to replacing the Liberals as state opposition in South Australia this year and may do so in NSW in March 2027. Some WA Liberals describe One Nation as “the opposition in waiting”. The Greens also have ambitions to replace Labor.

Even when One Nation and the Greens are unlikely to win government, it is useful for voters to hear from them. When Liberal and Labor disagree, it is often Greens on the crossbench who cast the deciding vote; after the Victorian election, One Nation may be in that position. Other countries often include multiple parties in debates, even those not in a position to form majority government. Wales had six party leaders in the debate; Canada four. There were several debates for the 2024 UK general election, with anywhere between two- and seven-party spokespeople depending on topic, format and host.

Australia is a multi-party democracy. The combined vote for the Labor and Liberal–National parties has declined sharply since the 1980s, and at the 2025 federal election more people voted for independents and minor parties than for Liberal–Nationals. Major party support has fallen further: the latest federal polling suggests fewer than half of Australians intend to vote for a major party. In Victorian state polls, One Nation is equal second with Labor on 22%, behind the Coalition on 31% (at time of writing).

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

About half of Victorians do not support the two major parties, so it seems fair that others are represented in the leaders’ debate.

At their best, debates test and challenge the policies of each party and see leaders present clear alternative governments. At last year’s federal election, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Opposition Leader Peter Dutton clashed at four debates. Dutton was pressed on his party’s nuclear policy, and Albanese on his apparently poor relationship with US President Donald Trump. Both articulated distinct positions on Welcome to Country ceremonies.

In Victoria, there are stark differences between parties. The Labor government has focused on infrastructure, only to face concerns about costs and criminal influence. The Liberals are planning to scrap Australia’s first treaty with Aboriginal Australians and other truth-telling and reconciliation work. One Nation apparently wants Victoria to receive less GST revenue because other Australians should not prop up “the most fiscally and morally bankrupt state”. The Greens have called for publicly owned supermarkets.

All these positions deserve interrogation. It is a shame that there will be only one debate, but it is fitting that it will feature the leaders of four very different political parties. And while I regret the paywall, it is unlikely the debate would have featured One Nation or the Greens if it were hosted by anyone but Sky News and the Herald Sun.

An independent debates commission would be welcome but is no longer necessary. The ABC and other free-to-air broadcasters have a new point of leverage for future debates: they can proceed with the debate even if one of the party leaders refuses to attend. With two speakers, it is impossible to hold a debate if one drops out. With four, it is perfectly feasible to proceed with the remaining three.

The competing plans for Victoria from the Labor, Liberal–National, One Nation and Green parties deserve scrutiny. Victorians will benefit from seeing these four visions debated tonight, but would have been better off with several debates, hosted by free-to-air and public broadcasters as well as subscription-based ones.

Bill Browne is Director of the Democracy & Accountability Program.

Related Articles

OPINION

‘Trust us’ isn’t nearly enough for this overreach – but it will likely work anyway

By Amy Remeikis

The overreach in the defence capability act changes is explained away with “trust us”. Trust us to consult (even though nothing happens if we don’t, and it doesn’t matter if you don’t want what we have decided – you have no rights of appeal).

Democracy & Accountability
‘Trust us’ isn’t nearly enough for this overreach – but it will likely work anyway

OPINION

Where did Labor’s ideas go?

By James Watson

One of the right's cliched critiques is that left governments privilege “ideology” above “reality”. It’s a critique that is both typically meaningless and a way for the right to imply that their own policy ideas are “rational” and “objective”. But in order to make this clichéd critique, you have to first assume that the left government you’re talking about at the very least has some distinct ideas.

Democracy & Accountability
Where did Labor’s ideas go?

OPINION

As nation loses its way on AI-generated deepfakes, NSW debates a better way forward

By Bill Browne

Today, the NSW Parliament will debate the case for truth in political advertising laws. It’s the culmination of a months-long petition in which over 31,000 NSW residents lent their names to the call for a ban on misleading ads.

Democracy & Accountability
As nation loses its way on AI-generated deepfakes, NSW debates a better way forward

OPINION

Quiet but sweeping defence changes are yet another blow to our public trust

By Amy Remeikis

The Coalition and Labor will most likely be in lockstep on the latest defence changes, a bill that sailed through the last House sitting while attention was mostly on estimates. It changes 14 different acts of legislation, while giving public servants ministerial powers to override state, territory and, in some cases, federal, laws if an area has been declared necessary for “defence capabilities”.

Democracy & Accountability
Quiet but sweeping defence changes are yet another blow to our public trust