Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

‘Trust us’ isn’t nearly enough for this overreach – but it will likely work anyway

The overreach in the defence capability act changes is explained away with “trust us”. Trust us to consult (even though nothing happens if we don’t, and it doesn’t matter if you don’t want what we have decided – you have no rights of appeal).

Amy Remeikis

Amy Remeikis

Mon 16 Nov 2026 11.46 AEDT

Democracy & Accountability
‘Trust us’ isn’t nearly enough for this overreach – but it will likely work anyway

Photo: AAP Image/Con Chronis

For the people who once upon a time handed out military command, high civil office, legions – everything, now restrains itself and anxiously hopes for just two things; bread and circuses.

Juvenal’s much quoted reference to panem et cicuenses looms large in out daily lives, and yes, you could argue it has ever been thus.

Keep the people fed – both in terms of bread and entertainment – and you can get away with almost anything.

And so, as Australian Cricket team captain Pat Cummins challenged for the record of Australia’s longest press conference over something that happened eight years ago, Australia’s mainstream media left everything from the weather to the announcement of a new counter-terrorism office (we love cops, but not deradicalisation programs, so now concerned parents can dob their children straight in to the cops – what could go wrong?!) to broadcast him.

From there, it was into the news that there was not enough evidence to charge Sydney Swans players for their most recent scandal.

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

We did, finally, get to a little from COP31, where Australia, like most of the West has continued the tradition of being disappointing, but again not too much. And, despite the numerous defence correspondents, we didn’t hear anything about one of the biggest changes to domestic defence powers in about 50 years.

The overreach in the defence capability act changes is explained away with “trust us”. Trust us to consult (even though nothing happens if we don’t, and it doesn’t matter if you don’t want what we have decided – you have no rights of appeal).

Trust us not to abuse the extraordinary powers granted in this bill to seize land and override laws for Australia’s “strategic” and “capability” interests. Trust us that, even though the minister can designate anything they want as a “defence zone”, it won’t be used indiscriminatorily – even though under the legislation it can include a vehicle that snapping a photograph of could land you in jail for up to two years.

There is also the fun “roving” defence declaration, which means defence can claim areas on a moving basis.  It doesn’t even have to be static.

The fact sheets that accompany the bill are filled with platitudes like how the legislation doesn’t intend on overriding native title or environmental laws, but sitting alongside it. But it also overrides laws – ones we don’t know about, because those laws aren’t listed.

Given the commitments and unanswered questions surrounding the second pillar of AUKUS, “just take our word for it” should not be good enough for anyone.

But it is apparently enough for both major parties – and the committee whose job is to review this legislation. The committee, which has only Labor and Coalition members after the major parties successfully teamed up to keep out the crossbench, heard only from the departments of Defence and Home Affairs, lobby groups and arms manufacturers in the hearing hastily organised to review this piece of legislative overreach.

Despite the scandalously short time frame for submissions, Maritime Union Australia, IPAN and other civil liberty and human rights groups mobilised to respond. But none of the Labor/Coalition members of the committee reviewing the law thought it necessary to hear their concerns in the hearing, which will be used to form the basis of their report to recommend the legislation be passed. Which is on track to be passed before the end of the year.

The hurry has not been explained. Nor has the secrecy. Asked by this column, Greens leader David Shoebridge said he too was shocked at the speed at which the bill was being rammed through the parliament.

“This bill is being sold as dealing with drones over Australian bases but it goes far beyond that. This introduces sweeping changes that, on initial reading, pose a serious risk to the right to protest and civil liberties,” he said.

“Given the hopelessly inadequate responses the Australian Defence Force has had to drone intrusions, there would be widespread support for legal reforms that gave them the powers needed to deal with drones. Unfortunately that’s not what this bill is designed to do.

“There are also serious issues around the right to protest. Labor is proposing laws that say if you in any way ‘obstruct’ defence activities, you get seven years in jail. All those people protesting at Pine Gap, protesting AUKUS are rightfully concerned about this.

“The minister can also just go around designating whatever he wants as a ‘defence zone’. He can make a truck a defence ‘zone’, and it turns into a mobile seven-year prison sentence if you in any way get in its way.

“The fact that Labor has funnelled this bill into their new secretive defence committee is deeply troubling. That committee is a rubber stamp populated only with the Liberals and Labor, who are in lockstep with Trump, lockstep with AUKUS, and dead against protest.”

But hey! The cricket amirite?! As John Oliver once quipped, “the easiest way to do evil is to make it boring”.

Amy Remeikis is a contributing editor for The New Daily and chief political analyst for The Australia Institute

This piece was first published in The New Daily. Read the original piece here

Related Articles

OPINION

Where did Labor’s ideas go?

By James Watson

One of the right's cliched critiques is that left governments privilege “ideology” above “reality”. It’s a critique that is both typically meaningless and a way for the right to imply that their own policy ideas are “rational” and “objective”. But in order to make this clichéd critique, you have to first assume that the left government you’re talking about at the very least has some distinct ideas.

Democracy & Accountability
Where did Labor’s ideas go?

OPINION

As nation loses its way on AI-generated deepfakes, NSW debates a better way forward

By Bill Browne

Today, the NSW Parliament will debate the case for truth in political advertising laws. It’s the culmination of a months-long petition in which over 31,000 NSW residents lent their names to the call for a ban on misleading ads.

Democracy & Accountability
As nation loses its way on AI-generated deepfakes, NSW debates a better way forward

OPINION

Quiet but sweeping defence changes are yet another blow to our public trust

By Amy Remeikis

The Coalition and Labor will most likely be in lockstep on the latest defence changes, a bill that sailed through the last House sitting while attention was mostly on estimates. It changes 14 different acts of legislation, while giving public servants ministerial powers to override state, territory and, in some cases, federal, laws if an area has been declared necessary for “defence capabilities”.

Democracy & Accountability
Quiet but sweeping defence changes are yet another blow to our public trust

OPINION

AI has been a flimsy excuse for government laziness, underfunding and secrecy

By Bill Browne

A lot of attention has been paid to the mischief done by “agentic” large language models (LLMs) on their own initiative. But the more immediate and commonplace danger is that AI will multiply and indulge existing human weaknesses. AI does not have to be super intelligent to provide an excuse for secretive and poor-quality government decision-making.

Democracy & AccountabilityArtificial Intelligence
AI has been a flimsy excuse for government laziness, underfunding and secrecy