Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

It’s not the size of your NOM that matters, it’s what you do with it that counts

As part of the ongoing political jockeying over the Net Overseas Migration (NOM) number, the Albanese Government has backed down on a plan to reduce the number of working-holiday makers allowed to come to Australia. But has it missed a chance for Australia to improve ties with the Pacific?

Morgan Harrington

Morgan Harrington

Wed 18 Nov 2026 14.04 AEDT

Society & Inequality
It’s not the size of your NOM that matters, it’s what you do with it that counts

Photo: AAP Image/Hilary Wardhaugh

As part of the ongoing political jockeying over the Net Overseas Migration (NOM) number, the Albanese Government has backed down on a plan to reduce the number of working-holiday makers allowed to come to Australia. But has it missed a chance for Australia to improve ties with the Pacific?

In September, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke announced changes that would have seen the number of working holiday makers in Australia drop significantly. Overall numbers were to be capped, and backpackers would have been required to enter a ballot if they wanted to extend their temporary work visa for a second or third year.

This week Minister Burke announced that the proposed ballot system would be delayed until early next year, and that the cap of 5,000 on the number of third year visas declared in September will be lifted to 25,000 (the current level is 31,000). The number of days that backpackers will have to spend working in regional Australia to qualify for a second-year visa will also increase, from 88 to 120 days.

The turnaround comes after backlash from the Nationals, employers, and communities in regional areas, who voiced concern that local businesses would have no one to wait restaurant tables, clean hotel rooms, or pick fruit.

Until this latest announcement, Minister Burke had insisted that instead of relying on backpackers, regional employers should make more use of the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) Scheme, which allows people from nine Pacific Island nations and Timor-Leste to work in Australia on a temporary basis.

Like the Working Holiday Maker program, the PALM scheme allows people from other countries to live and work in Australia with the understanding that the arrangement is temporary. But unlike backpackers, who can work just about anywhere someone will hire them, PALM visa holders can only work for the employer who sponsors their visa. Since sponsoring a PALM visa is a lot more complicated and costly than hiring a backpacker, Burke’s suggestion was not well received – hence the policy shift.

With reports that backpackers had already started to leave, employers in regional Australia must be celebrating the Minister’s changes. Behind the technicalities of numbers and visa classes, however, lies a much bigger question of what Australia’s temporary visa programs are for, beyond the need for able bodies in regional areas.

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

It seems that Australia is again choosing between its history and its geography. Working Holiday visas are available to people from a hodgepodge of nations, mostly but not exclusively in Europe. In contrast, the PALM scheme is designed to strengthen ties between Australia and the Pacific region that is vital to broader strategic goals.

The PALM scheme offers something that, with the exception of New Zealand, others in the Asia-Pacific can’t: access to the Australian labour market, and the ability to earn Australian dollars. This gives the PALM scheme the potential to become a powerful diplomatic tool. This means that regional Australia’s need for foreign workers is also an opportunity for Australia to form closer people-to-people ties with the Pacific nations that are key to Australia’s security and prosperity. Decisions about who is allowed to do the labouring Australians apparently won’t do is, therefore, about a lot more than raw numbers.

Which brings us back to the difficulties in hiring PALM workers. Employers are right: it is a lot easier to hire a backpacker (who can be paid by the hour) than it is to go through the process of sponsoring a PALM visa (which lasts for a minimum of nine months).

The principal obstacle to greater flexibility within the PALM scheme is that employers pay the upfront costs associated with bringing someone from the Pacific or Timor-Leste to work in Australia. This includes the cost of visa application fees, flights, transport to the worksite, and even accommodation. Workers then repay these costs through deductions from their paycheques.

Not only is that more complicated for employers, but these deductions are the source of serious concerns about the PALM scheme. If Australia expects access to its labour market to work as a form of soft power, everyone with the right to work in Australia should be treated fairly, including PALM workers (and, for that matter, backpackers). Removing the power imbalance created when a PALM worker’s visa status is tied to their employer is a good place to start.

But there is a simple way to change this dynamic and fill the labour shortages in regional Australia. If the Australian Government provided loans to cover the costs of coming to Australia under the PALM scheme, and managed repayments through the tax system, employers wouldn’t have to worry about recovering their expenses, and visa holders would be free to choose where they work. This would give both employers and employees exactly the kind of flexibility the regions say they need. More importantly, it would mean that Australia is not simply “filling gaps” in the domestic labour market, but using regional partnerships to help improve living standards across the Pacific. 

Morgan Harrington is a research manager at The Australia Institute.

Related Articles

OPINION

Australia’s gender pay gap falls below 20% for the first time

By Gemma Killen

Australia's gender pay gap has fallen to a record low. This year, the pay gap is 19.7%, which means that for every dollar men earn, women earn just over 80 cents. Over a year, this adds up to an average difference of $27,467.

Society & InequalityEconomy
Australia’s gender pay gap falls below 20% for the first time

EXPLAINER

What is the Digital Duty of Care, and will it work?

By Skye Predavec

Under the Digital Duty of Care, online platforms would have a duty to ensure Australians have a safe online environment, where they are “protected from seriously harmful material and conduct”.

Democracy & AccountabilitySociety & Inequality
What is the Digital Duty of Care, and will it work?

OPINION

Struggling to parent in the neoliberal economy? You’re not alone.

By Belinda Eslick

Labor needs to offer more than universal childcare if it wants to increase the fertility rate and address the motherhood penalty—parents are overworked, burnt out, and want more time for what matters.

Society & Inequality
Struggling to parent in the neoliberal economy? You’re not alone.

OPINION

Career education shouldn’t end when school does

By Kira Clarke

We know high schools provide some level of career information—and what that looks like varies considerably between schools. But very little attention has been paid to what happens after young people leave their school's gates for the last time.

Society & InequalityEducation
Career education shouldn’t end when school does