Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

From Queensland clinics to the UN floor: Why Trans lives are not bargaining chips

Every year on November 20, Transgender Day of Remembrance asks us to read out the names of the dead. As a trans woman of colour living in Australia, I have always felt the weight of this day as an inventory of survival. Yet this Friday, the grief feels sharper. The institutions claiming to protect human rights are actively electing to disregard the situation, both domestically and within the United Nations.

Aisya A. Zaharin

Aisya A. Zaharin

Fri 20 Nov 2026 13.49 AEDT

Society & Inequality
From Queensland clinics to the UN floor: Why Trans lives are not bargaining chips

Photo: supplied

Every year on November 20, Transgender Day of Remembrance asks us to read out the names of the dead. As a trans woman of colour living in Australia, I have always felt the weight of this day as an inventory of survival. Yet today, the grief feels sharper. The institutions claiming to protect human rights are actively electing to disregard the situation, both domestically and within the United Nations.

Here in so-called Australia, we like to imagine ourselves insulated from the worst excesses of global anti-trans hostility. That illusion shattered again this week. Despite interim guidelines from Australia’s peak medical research body, the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC), affirming that puberty blockers should remain a clinical option for trans youth, politicians in Queensland and the Northern Territory refused to budge on their bans in public hospitals.

In Queensland, the ban has been extended until 2031, despite prior legal challenges, as state authorities prioritised ideological positions over the highest medical guidance available in the country. By overriding the recommendations of doctors, clinicians, and families, state leaders opted for political objectives at the expense of the autonomy and well-being of transgender youth.

To understand why domestic bans on healthcare are so dangerous, we only have to look at what happened at the United Nations last Thursday.

For the first time after decades of progress, the United States voted to remove gay and trans people from the list of vulnerable groups the international community promises to protect from targeted, unlawful killings. Put forward by Egypt on behalf of a bloc of Muslim-majority nations, the amendment sought to strip explicit references to sexual orientation and gender identity from a crucial UN committee resolution on extrajudicial executions. The amendment narrowly failed by 74 votes to 69, with Washington and Beijing voting together in favour of erasure.

The speed of this diplomatic collapse is staggering. In 2010, when the very same UN committee cut sexual orientation from the resolution, the United States led the international campaign to put it back. Just two years ago, a similar attempt to erase us was defeated comfortably, 78 votes to 47. Today, that margin has shrunk to a razor-thin five votes. While the resolution ultimately passed with protections intact, it heads to the full General Assembly in December, where that same fight will play out all over again.

When powerful countries vote to erase us from human rights documents, they are giving a green light to impunity. A recent report by the LGBTQ+ rights group Outright International documented more than 230 targeted killings of queer and trans people across every region of the world since 2020, with victims as young as 12 years old. For trans women of colour, we bear the overwhelming brunt of fatal violence globally.

By refusing to label us as victims of hate, authorities absolve themselves of the duty to examine our killings, bring perpetrators to justice, or ensure the protection of our children.

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

This is why politicians, especially those who call themselves progressive or moderate, must stop playing respectability politics with our lives.

For too long, political leaders have treated trans rights as a PR liability, conceding ground on trans youth, sports, or healthcare in the false hope that throwing a small, marginalized group under the bus will appease conservative critics. It never works.

Respectability politics asks trans people to deny ourselves, to prove we are palatable, quiet, and “non-threatening” in exchange for conditional tolerance. Yet history shows that concessions only whet the appetite of reactionaries.

Worse still, this relentless culture war is a deliberate trap designed to keep ordinary people divided. As politicians manufacture panic over puberty blockers in Brisbane or bathroom access in Washington, they are weaponizing fear to pit cisgender women against trans women, and working-class families against queer youth.

Every hour spent debating our right to exist in public life is an hour diverted from stagnant wages, unaffordable housing, crumbling public healthcare, and corporate profiteering.

This culture war serves no one except the ruling class. It fractures the solidarity required for women, LGBTQ+ people, racialised communities, and the working class to challenge the economic and political systems actually harming them.

On this Trans Day of Remembrance, mourning is not enough. We do not need performative sympathy from leaders who deny healthcare to trans teenagers by day and express condolences for murdered trans adults by night. Authentic Remembrance requires political courage that defends bodily autonomy in our clinics, holding the line at the UN General Assembly this December, and refuse to let our lives be used as collateral in this distractive war.

Aisya A. Zaharin is a doctoral researcher and migration policy analyst with Scarlet Alliance, and a member of the AHRC Trans and Gender Diverse Expert Advisory Committee. You can read the Australian Human Rights Equal Identities Report at:  Equal Identities: Trans and Gender Diverse Rights

Related Articles

OPINION

Women are being killed in the NT. The CLP would rather wage a culture war

By (A)manda Parkinson

In a Territory where women are being killed, families are losing their homes and maternity services are disappearing, the Country Liberal Party has found a much easier enemy. 

Society & Inequality
Women are being killed in the NT. The CLP would rather wage a culture war

WHAT'S NEW

Calls grow for Queensland Government to overturn puberty blocker ban following new medical advice

By Tegan George

The Queensland Government is facing renewed pressure to overturn its restrictions on puberty blockers for young transgender people, following new advice from Australia’s peak medical research body supporting their use in certain circumstances.

Society & InequalityHealth
Calls grow for Queensland Government to overturn puberty blocker ban following new medical advice

EXPLAINER

Why is the federal government subsidising AI slop?

By Skye Predavec

A low-traffic website filled with AI-generated “news” is unremarkable. These kinds of websites now litter the internet, after all. But the Northern Beaches Buzz does stand out from the others in one important respect – it’s being subsidised by the Commonwealth Government.  

Society & Inequality
Why is the federal government subsidising AI slop?

OPINION

It’s not the size of your NOM that matters, it’s what you do with it that counts

By Morgan Harrington

As part of the ongoing political jockeying over the Net Overseas Migration (NOM) number, the Albanese Government has backed down on a plan to reduce the number of working-holiday makers allowed to come to Australia. But has it missed a chance for Australia to improve ties with the Pacific?

Society & Inequality
It’s not the size of your NOM that matters, it’s what you do with it that counts