Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

We don't need another inquiry to know that Australia is torturing its children

A landmark Senate Inquiry into Youth Justice and Incarceration has just handed down its latest report into Australia’s youth prisons. However, we must listen to the words of the children who survive behind its pages. 

Satara Uthayakumaran

Satara Uthayakumaran

Fri 2 Oct 2026 11.13 AEST

Society & Inequality
We don't need another inquiry to know that Australia is torturing its children

Photo: AAP Image/(A)manda Parkinson

They stripped me in my cell. The moment they pulled my pants down…that’s when I stopped feeling like a human.

Those are the words of a fourteen-year-old boy held inside Ashley Youth Detention Centre in Tasmania. A child.

Last year, as the former Australian Youth Representative to the United Nations, I conducted the largest face-to-face listening tour of young people in 2025. I searched for the children this country chooses to forget.

What I found broke my heart.

A landmark Senate Inquiry into Youth Justice and Incarceration has just handed down its latest report into Australia’s youth prisons. However, we must listen to the words of the children who survive behind its pages.

Inside Bimberi Youth Justice Centre in the ACT, a 15-year-old girl pressed a letter into my hands.

Most of the time we are locked in our cells for up to 17 hours. I have watched Bimberi use force on a young person for 20 mins… Bimberi Health doesn’t listen to or help with female problems like endometriosis. They refuse to give heat packs or adequate medication. No kid in here knows when they will get out. It is impossible to get help. The system is not working. End of story.

I have sat across from ten-year-olds behind these walls. Children so tiny, their legs still swing from their chairs.

Instead of stumbling through their first lessons, or falling asleep safe in the arms of someone who loves them, we hand them to strangers with handcuffs.

In the words of a group of young men I met from Cobham Juvenile Justice Centre in NSW:

We’re still sons, brothers, friends. Some of us are artists, some are cooks…some write music. But when we’re locked up, people stop seeing us as human. They stop believing we can change.

It is these voices which I recently brought as evidence before the Senate Inquiry. The Committee, having now handed down its final report, proposed four key recommendations:

Firstly, the coordination of national minimum standards in youth detention facilities across all states and territories to ensure fair, consistent treatment of youth offenders across Australia.

Secondly, a cross-portfolio taskforce to tackle reform of the youth detention system, comprised of services from all states and territories – including child justice, policing, social services, health services, legal services and more.

Thirdly, a national education campaign around children in conflict with the law, and how alternatives to incarceration actually benefit community safety.

And finally, another Senate inquiry into the factors leading to youth incarceration.

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

These recommendations are worth our attention, but are they enough to change a child’s life?

Several of the recommendations focus on gathering more information, more data. But this is not a scarce resource. We have known the causes of youth crime for decades. We see the poverty, the failure of social services, the inability of government departments to communicate with one another. We know that our children are dying in custody. We do not require another inquiry or even an education campaign to tell us the same things. What we need is the political spine to act on what we already know.

The Commonwealth must definitively ban spit hoods and solitary confinement – both recognised as forms of torture – invoking its constitutional power under Section 51(xxix), to override state and territory laws that violate the rights of children in our prisons.

We need more funding for community-led alternatives: rehabilitation programs, opportunities, upskilling and employment pathways. A prevention-led approach which invests in the village that surrounds every child is imperative.

But the report’s most glaring omission is perhaps its greatest tragedy: there is no agreement to raise the age of criminal responsibility. We cannot talk about protecting children while it remains legal to treat a ten-year-old as an adult criminal. We must raise the minimum age to 14. Nationwide. Immediately.

Last year, the government declared that a 15-year-old is too vulnerable to safely exist on social media. The message from our leaders rang out clear: we must “protect” our children.

The contradiction is impossible to ignore. We have decided that a teenager cannot navigate an algorithm, but a 10-year-old can navigate a courtroom. We shield adolescents from screens, but subject children to strip searches. We fear the harm of the digital world but accept the damage of a concrete cage.

Right now, Prime Minister Albanese is in New York, lobbying for a seat on the UN Security Council.

Despite frequently leveraging Indigenous culture on the world stage to build “diplomatic capital”, the Prime Minister recently dismissed concerns that the UN had raised Australia’s treatment of Indigenous children with him.

Let me be clear: that is a fiction. The UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination explicitly and severely condemned Australia for its treatment of Indigenous children caught in these systems – in particular, the caging of these children at catastrophic rates.

You cannot champion human rights in New York while torturing children on Australian soil. By strapping spit hoods to the faces of terrified children, we are in active, undeniable breach of international law.

I began this piece with the words of a child held inside a Tasmanian prison, and that is exactly how I will end. And this 15-year-old told me to take his message directly to the leader of this country:

Prime Minister, I strongly believe that you should come to Ashley Youth Detention Centre so that you can hear our voices in person… It will break your heart…

These children may never read this Senate report. They will, however, live with what it produces, or indeed fails to produce.

Its significance won’t be measured by neat recommendations, but in whether a ten-year-old will have yet another spit hood forced on their head. In whether a child is left in isolation for days without sunlight. In whether our children – who are crying out to us from the dark – can eventually see some trace of their own humanity in what Australia does next.

Satara Uthayakumaran is a writer and the former Australian Youth Representative to the United Nations. 

Related Articles

OPINION

Adding life to our years, not years to our lives

By Luke Slawomirski

How long we live is only part of the story. What matters just as much is how long we remain healthy. And on that measure, we have a problem.

Society & InequalityHealth
Adding life to our years, not years to our lives

OPINION

All discrimination is wrong, unless you are a kid from a poor family

By Jane Caro AM

Discrimination is literally what private, fee-charging schools are about. They are transactional, designed to provide a private and positional good for the families who can pay their fees. Only public schools have any obligation to the public good – aka educating every child. The clue is in the name.

Society & Inequality
All discrimination is wrong, unless you are a kid from a poor family

OPINION

Victorian children who commit minor and low-level crimes don’t need ‘tough love’. They need connection and prevention

By David Jeffery

The Victorian Premier’s announcement of mandatory court-ordered rehabilitation for young people found guilty of low-level offences such as theft, vandalism, property damage and minor assaults isn’t entirely without merit. But the money could be better spent than on youth prison. Those of us working in youth and community services know that lasting reductions in crime come from prevention.

Society & Inequality
Victorian children who commit minor and low-level crimes don’t need ‘tough love’. They need connection and prevention

WHAT'S NEW

Australia in the minority of countries without official poverty measure as experts push for change

By Tegan George

Despite being one of the world’s wealthiest countries, Australia still lacks an official national poverty measure, making it hard to track whether efforts to reduce disadvantage are working.

Society & Inequality
Australia in the minority of countries without official poverty measure as experts push for change