Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

The inverse care law: how private healthcare can increase pressure on public hospitals

Private health care is supposed to take pressure off public hospitals. Sometimes it can do the opposite. When scarce clinical resources are used where they’re least needed, public patients wait longer.

Luke Slawomirski

Luke Slawomirski

Wed 4 Nov 2026 11.59 AEDT

Society & InequalityHealth
The inverse care law: how private healthcare can increase pressure on public hospitals

Photo: AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts

Republish this article

This article is licensed under Creative Commons — Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0).

Republishing guidelines

  • You must credit the author(s) and The Point.
  • You must link back to the original article.
  • You may not edit or modify the article content.
  • Images may be subject to separate copyright and are not included in this licence.

When his government introduced the private health insurance rebate, John Howard said:

The name of the game is to get volume, to get large numbers of people taking out health insurance to take the load off the public hospital system.

But this doesn’t work when people with the least need receive the most health care, while those with the greatest need are made to wait.

This medical segregation is called the ‘inverse care law’.

The inverse care law is very evident in Australia. This challenges not only our egalitarian self-image but also the claim that private care supports public hospitals.

Colonoscopy: a procedure of affluence

Colonoscopies – where a flexible tube is used to examine the bowel, take biopsies and remove abnormalities like cancer if needed – illustrate how the current system misallocates scarce resources.

Our most affluent communities appear to receive more privately-funded colonoscopies than everyone else. After adjusting for age, a person living in Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs North – an area that includes suburbs like Vaucluse and Double Bay – is 39 times more likely to get a colonoscopy than someone in Katherine, NT.

These data exclude most public hospital patients (except those who are funded privately – roughly 10%), but the entire clinical pathway points in the same direction.

According to the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW), Australia’s poorest communities are less likely to participate in bowel cancer screening (36% versus 47%), more likely to receive a positive result (6.9% v 4.7%), less likely to undergo the subsequent diagnostic assessment (80.8% v 89.1%), and more likely to wait longer for it (71 days v 50 days).

AIHW data also show that around three-quarters of same-day colonoscopies occur in private hospitals.

Meanwhile, NSW Health estimates that about 20,000 public endoscopy procedures – most of which are colonoscopies – may be overdue.

But the most telling statistic is bowel cancer mortality – which is about 50% higher among Australia’s poorest communities compared to the most affluent, according to the latest available data.

Repeat colonoscopies (performed within three years of a prior one) reveal the same pattern. Clinical guidelines recommend these be performed on a small number of high-risk patients.

There’s little reason to think the clinical need for early repeat colonoscopy is concentrated among affluent Australians. Disadvantaged communities have higher rates of positive screening results and bowel-cancer mortality. Yet they receive fewer repeat procedures.

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

How does this help public hospital patients?

Colonoscopy shows how private activity can lengthen public waiting lists. Both sectors draw on the same limited pool of gastroenterologists. When these specialists perform unnecessary or premature procedures, they cannot use that time for higher-risk patients waiting elsewhere.

The imbalance is considerable. If rates in high-use affluent areas fell towards the national average, and rates in disadvantaged areas rose by the same total amount, about 11,700 repeat and 57,600 initial colonoscopies could shift each year without increasing overall activity.

This calculation merely serves to illustrate the scale of the unevenness. Clinical need and guidelines would still determine access. Reductions would come only from unnecessary or premature procedures, so affluent patients who do need a colonoscopy would not miss out.

Other examples of medical segregation

Knee arthroscopies are another example of the inverse care law at work in the Australian health system.

While arthroscopy can be appropriate for some injuries and other specific conditions, using it to treat osteoarthritis and degenerative knee disease is a well-established example of low-value care because it generally provides little benefit over non-surgical treatment and carries risks of harm.

According to the AIHW, private hospitals recorded 38,747 arthroscopic knee procedures in 2024–25, compared with 7,269 in public hospitals. Private hospitals therefore performed about 84% of these procedures, despite accounting for about 67% of elective surgery overall. The private rate appears to be 2.65 times the public rate – which is striking for a procedure with a long history of overuse.

A similar mismatch is evident in cardiology.

A 2016 study that examined geographic variation in coronary angiography – an invasive test used to identify narrowing or blockages in the blood vessels supplying the heart – found that rates varied more than five-fold. Even though socioeconomic disadvantage and remoteness were associated with higher rates of heart disease and death, higher income areas had higher angiography rates. The strongest predictor of an area’s angiography rate was private hospital activity.

And guess which income quintile uses private hospitals (and private health insurance) the most?

Inequitable and inefficient

A health system that gives lower-risk, affluent patients procedures they may not need while higher-risk public patients wait is both inequitable and inefficient.

It means each dollar we spend buys less health than it could.

The private health insurance rebate costs $8 billion a year, and about $12 billion if indirect costs are included. At a time when the government is seeking $9.3 billion in budget savings, this generous subsidy deserves closer scrutiny.

John Howard said the rebate’s purpose was to “take the load off the public hospital system”. When subsidised private care consumes scarce resources on low-value procedures while higher-risk public patients wait, the policy is doing the opposite.

Luke Slawomirski is Senior Postdoctoral Research Fellow at The Australia Institute.

Related Articles

OPINION

Adding life to our years, not years to our lives

By Luke Slawomirski

How long we live is only part of the story. What matters just as much is how long we remain healthy. And on that measure, we have a problem.

Society & InequalityHealth
Adding life to our years, not years to our lives

OPINION

All discrimination is wrong, unless you are a kid from a poor family

By Jane Caro AM

Discrimination is literally what private, fee-charging schools are about. They are transactional, designed to provide a private and positional good for the families who can pay their fees. Only public schools have any obligation to the public good – aka educating every child. The clue is in the name.

Society & Inequality
All discrimination is wrong, unless you are a kid from a poor family

OPINION

Victorian children who commit minor and low-level crimes don’t need ‘tough love’. They need connection and prevention

By David Jeffery

The Victorian Premier’s announcement of mandatory court-ordered rehabilitation for young people found guilty of low-level offences such as theft, vandalism, property damage and minor assaults isn’t entirely without merit. But the money could be better spent than on youth prison. Those of us working in youth and community services know that lasting reductions in crime come from prevention.

Society & Inequality
Victorian children who commit minor and low-level crimes don’t need ‘tough love’. They need connection and prevention

WHAT'S NEW

Australia in the minority of countries without official poverty measure as experts push for change

By Tegan George

Despite being one of the world’s wealthiest countries, Australia still lacks an official national poverty measure, making it hard to track whether efforts to reduce disadvantage are working.

Society & Inequality
Australia in the minority of countries without official poverty measure as experts push for change