Skip to main content
Advanced search
The Point - home
DonateSubscribe
HomeWhat's NewOpinionOff the ChartsExplainersFactcheckAbout Us
The Point — home
DonateSubscribe
The Point — home
Advanced search
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
DonateSubscribe
Subscribe
  • Home
  • What's New
  • Opinion
  • Off the Charts
  • Explainers
  • Factcheck
  • About Us
The Point - home
Privacy PolicySitemapComplaints & CorrectionsNewsletter

The Point recognises the ancestral connections and custodianship of Traditional Owners throughout Australia. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and to Elders past and present.

©2025–2026 The Point, an initiative of The Australia Institute

OPINION

Why scrapping the extra private health rebate for over-65s won’t necessarily add pressure to public hospitals

It should not be assumed that every private hospital service is essential care that would otherwise have to be performed in a public hospital. Like the public system, private healthcare delivers excellent and necessary care. But it also delivers care of little or uncertain value. Australian research has demonstrated low-value procedures in the private sector.

Luke Slawomirski

Luke Slawomirski

Tue 29 Sep 2026 10.18 AEST

Society & InequalityHealth
Why scrapping the extra private health rebate for over-65s won’t necessarily add pressure to public hospitals

Photo: AAP Image/Jay Kogler

Republish this article

This article is licensed under Creative Commons — Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0).

Republishing guidelines

  • You must credit the author(s) and The Point.
  • You must link back to the original article.
  • You may not edit or modify the article content.
  • Images may be subject to separate copyright and are not included in this licence.

Parliamentary Budget Office analysis has added fuel to the debate over the government’s plan to remove the extra private health insurance (PHI) rebate for people aged 65 and over.

Commissioned by independent MP Monique Ryan, the analysis finds that about $1.6 billion of the government’s expected $3 billion in savings over four years would come from people receiving the Age Pension. Around 1.5 million insured people aged 65 and over are estimated to receive at least some pension.

Under the proposed change, Australians aged 65 and over will receive the same means-tested PHI rebate as everyone else, thus removing the current four-percentage-point uplift for over 65s (eight for those 70 and over). As we have argued, younger Australians already subsidise their older compatriots through Community Rating, which prohibits insurers from basing premiums on age and pre-existing medical conditions.

Pensioners have less capacity than wealthy retirees to absorb higher premiums, so there’s a reasonable argument for targeting assistance according to financial need.

But the media release accompanying the Budget Office analysis falls into a familiar trap. It argues that people dropping or downgrading their insurance will increase pressure on public hospitals and shift costs from Canberra to the states.

But government modelling and independent research expect the hospital impact to be marginal. There are two main reasons why: private hospitals provide a lot of low value care; and they compete with public hospital for the same scarce resources.

Low-value care

It should not be assumed that every private hospital service is essential care that would otherwise have to be performed in a public hospital.

Like the public system, private healthcare delivers excellent and necessary care. But it also delivers care of little or uncertain value. Australian research has demonstrated low-value procedures in the private sector, while the Australian Atlas of Healthcare Variation has repeatedly found large and unexplained differences in age-adjusted rates in procedures such as knee arthroscopy, invasive coronary tests and lumbar spine surgery. If somebody forgoes an unnecessary knee arthroscopy because they no longer have top private cover, there’s not necessarily a corresponding public hospital admission.

Public hospitals, meanwhile, juggle the majority of complex patients and emergencies (94% of strokes and 86% of heart attacks are treated in the public sector). And this is in addition to elective surgery – for which waits are growing.

Counting every lost private procedure as additional public demand thus exaggerates the transfer of medical need.

Get our newsletter

Quality research, analysis, explainers and factchecks from experts you can trust.

Public care and private care compete for the same resources

The other problem is that the private and public systems are routinely spoken about as though they were two separate production lines, with private taking load off the public.

This ignores the reality that they share many of the same critical inputs.

Most medical care in private hospitals is provided by visiting specialists rather than doctors employed by the hospital. Public hospitals, meanwhile, employ almost 60,000 salaried medical officers and undertake the great bulk of emergency care. In 2024–25, 95% of surgery in private hospitals was elective, compared with 65% in public hospitals, while 27% of public-hospital surgery was emergency surgery.

So, increasing private activity does not necessarily create new health-system capacity, because surgeons and anaesthetists cannot be in two hospitals at once. More private elective activity can simply move scarce labour around the system.

Are taxpayers getting value for money?

When comparing the value of private health insurance, it is important to remember that private hospitals receive substantial public support. Through the PHI rebate, the Australian taxpayer directly contributes about $8 billion – a third of private-hospital funding – even before we count Medicare spending. That money could go directly to public hospitals, primary care or aged care.

Funding services directly, rather than through a circuitous route via insurers and private hospitals, was a key point in The Australia Institute’s submission on the proposed change to the PHI rebate.

The relevant question is how much valuable care the PHI rebate actually buys, not how much private activity disappears, and whether spending the same money elsewhere would produce greater health benefits.

Redirecting savings from reducing the PHI rebate for people over 65 into aged care could relieve hospital pressure more directly by helping patients leave hospital once they no longer need acute care.

Luke Slawomirski is a Senior Postdoctoral Research Fellow at The Australia Institute. He is a health economist, policy analyst and former clinician.

Related Articles

OPINION

It’s not the size of your NOM that matters, it’s what you do with it that counts

By Morgan Harrington

As part of the ongoing political jockeying over the Net Overseas Migration (NOM) number, the Albanese Government has backed down on a plan to reduce the number of working-holiday makers allowed to come to Australia. But has it missed a chance for Australia to improve ties with the Pacific?

Society & Inequality
It’s not the size of your NOM that matters, it’s what you do with it that counts

OPINION

Australia’s gender pay gap falls below 20% for the first time

By Gemma Killen

Australia's gender pay gap has fallen to a record low. This year, the pay gap is 19.7%, which means that for every dollar men earn, women earn just over 80 cents. Over a year, this adds up to an average difference of $27,467.

Society & InequalityEconomy
Australia’s gender pay gap falls below 20% for the first time

EXPLAINER

What is the Digital Duty of Care, and will it work?

By Skye Predavec

Under the Digital Duty of Care, online platforms would have a duty to ensure Australians have a safe online environment, where they are “protected from seriously harmful material and conduct”.

Democracy & AccountabilitySociety & Inequality
What is the Digital Duty of Care, and will it work?

OPINION

Struggling to parent in the neoliberal economy? You’re not alone.

By Belinda Eslick

Labor needs to offer more than universal childcare if it wants to increase the fertility rate and address the motherhood penalty—parents are overworked, burnt out, and want more time for what matters.

Society & Inequality
Struggling to parent in the neoliberal economy? You’re not alone.